Real Estate Legacy Group
A pumpkin pie on a charcoal kitchen island in a warmly lit walnut kitchen, with bare November branches beyond the window.

Your Broadview Heights Thanksgiving Pie Order, Day by Day

Every Thanksgiving errand in this post is on Broadview Road. Michael Angelo's Bakery is at 8035 Broadview Road in Broadview Heights. Michael Angelo's Winery is about 5 miles south at 5515 Broadview Road in Richfield. Olesia's Taverne, one of the nearest places serving a sit-down Thanksgiving dinner this year, is at 3960 Broadview Road, also in Richfield.

All of Michael Angelo's online pie orders share one deadline. Pickup works differently: the bakery gives you three days and the winery gives you two hours. You choose the pickup counter at checkout, and that choice sets which days and hours you can collect your order.

Before Sunday, November 22: choose your pickup counter

Michael Angelo's posts its Thanksgiving menu as two separate online collections. One is for pickup at the bakery in Broadview Heights. The other, called Winery Thanksgiving Express Pickup, is for pickup at the winery in Richfield. The bakery page says plainly that its orders are "for bakery pickup only" and links winery customers to the other collection.

The winery's Express Pickup collection link has "christmas-eve-pick-up" in the web address, but the page it opens is the Thanksgiving winery menu. Use the link on the bakery page and you'll land in the right place.

Both collections close online orders on Sunday, November 22. From the day this post goes up, that leaves Thursday, Friday, Saturday and Sunday to settle on pies and a pickup counter.

Most of the menu is the same in both collections. On the bakery menu, a plain pumpkin pie is $16, and pumpkin with whipped cream is $19.50. Apple, Dutch apple, chocolate cream, pecan, peanut butter mousse, cherry and banana cream are all $19.50. The pumpkin roll is $24. The turkey cakes are $28 for the stuffed version and $48 for the large one. The winery collection lists the same core items at the same prices, including the pumpkin pies, apple pie, pumpkin roll and turkey cakes.

The holiday pie special is the detail to read twice. Buy three pies online and the bakery adds a complimentary cream pie. To get it, put all four pies in your cart, the free one included, and enter HOLIDAYPIES at checkout. On the 2026 bakery menu, three $19.50 pies come to $58.50, and the fourth pie comes with them. The winery collection advertises the same offer. If you're bringing dessert for a big table, the three-pie order is the one to plan around.

Monday, November 23 through Wednesday, November 25: the bakery window

Bakery pickups run Monday, November 23 through Wednesday, November 25, during regular bakery hours. That is the more forgiving of the two options. A Monday pickup works for anyone traveling early or hosting a Tuesday Friendsgiving. A Tuesday pickup works for people who want pies in the refrigerator before the Wednesday rush.

The last bakery pickup is Wednesday, November 25 by 3:00 p.m., and the bakery's page says there are no pickups after that hour. If you work a standard day and planned to grab pies on the drive home Wednesday evening, that plan won't work. The counter has stopped handing out orders before most commutes start.

Michael Ciocca opened the bakery on Broadview Road in October 2000. He and his brother Matt are behind both the bakery and the Richfield winery. Custom cakes and Italian pastries made its local reputation over the past 26 years, so for many families the Thanksgiving pie order fits into an ordering routine they already have.

Wednesday, November 25, 10 a.m. to noon: the winery window

The Richfield option is much narrower. Winery Express Pickup happens on Wednesday, November 25, from 10:00 a.m. to 12:00 p.m., and only at the winery. There are no Monday or Tuesday pickups and no afternoon slot.

That two-hour window suits a specific kind of Wednesday. If you're off work the day before Thanksgiving, are already headed south toward Richfield or the Ohio Turnpike, or have family coming up from the Akron side, picking up at the winery may be easier than going north to the bakery. If your Wednesday morning is spoken for, order from the bakery collection.

Michael Angelo's Winery opened in 2018, according to cleveland.com. When it opened, cleveland.com described it as a winery-restaurant with a large patio and its own bakery area serving éclairs and macarons. We noted the difference between the two addresses back in September in our post on the Firefighters' Clambake. It matters more this week, because each order can be picked up only at the counter you chose.

Wednesday night: the evening before the holiday

By Wednesday night, both Michael Angelo's pickups are over. That evening, Wild Eagle Steak & Saloon in Broadview Heights is hosting its "Lets Get Basted Thanksgiving Eve Party," with live music by The Ladies Night starting at 9:00 p.m. on Wednesday, November 25, 2026. The event listing gives the date, time and band. If you have college students home for the break or friends in town for one night, it's an in-town plan that doesn't involve a drive into Cleveland.

Thursday, November 26: if you're not cooking

Michael Angelo's Bakery is closed on Thanksgiving Day. Anything you want from it has to be ordered by Sunday and picked up by Wednesday at 3 p.m.

If you'd rather someone else cooked the turkey, Olesia's Taverne in Richfield is serving a family-style Thanksgiving dinner from 11 a.m. to 3:30 p.m. The Akron Beacon Journal lists it at $60 per person and $28 for children ages 4 to 11. The spread includes turkey, glazed ham, sides and dessert, and reservations are taken by phone at 234-400-0288.

The same listing has Olesia's Thanksgiving takeout at $90 for two or $160 for four, with the same general spread. For a household of two adults and two children in that age range, dining in at the 2026 prices comes to $176. Takeout for four is $160 and lets you eat at your own table. Ask about takeout timing when you call, since the listing gives prices but not pickup details.

If you want the full holiday meal with a farther drive, The Aviator Pub & Restaurant on Brookpark Road in Cleveland lists a Thanksgiving brunch buffet from 9 a.m. to 2 p.m. at $68 for adults and $25 for children ages 4 to 12, per Cleveland Magazine. Its take-and-bake meal starts at $190, with pickup beginning at 3 p.m. on Wednesday, November 25.

Putting the week together

For most Broadview Heights households, a good plan comes down to two calls made before Sunday. First, order the pies, and decide which counter you'll pick up from before you click checkout. The bakery's Monday through Wednesday window is easiest on a work week. The winery's Wednesday morning slot is easier only if you're already headed toward Richfield. Second, if anyone at your table wants a night off from cooking, call Olesia's for a reservation or takeout.

If you're unsure which collection you ordered from, or have a question about an order, call the bakery at 440-526-0499 before Wednesday. If you need a pie on Thursday morning, no one at either counter will be there to pick up the phone.

Some of the most useful local knowledge in Broadview Heights is a calendar detail like a 3 p.m. Wednesday cutoff or a two-hour pickup window in Richfield. The Real Estate Legacy Group is based right here in Broadview Heights, and our neighborhood page is a good place to start for anyone getting to know the town. If a holiday visit has relatives asking what homes here are worth, or what it's like to live a short drive from the family table, schedule a free consultation and we'll talk it through with you.

Work With Us

From first conversation to closing, our unwavering commitment is to deliver honest guidance, professional execution, and results that leave every client confident and satisfied.

Follow Me on Instagram